My Modern Metropolis

Should man be punished for being naked in his home?

Erick Williamson, 29, continued to believe that he had done nothing wrong and that he did not purposely expose himself to two women and a 7-year-old boy who walked past his house the morning of Oct. 19. He immediately appealed his conviction. "That's outrageous," he said after the verdict. "It's unbelievable." He said publicity from the arrest had cost him a job as a commercial diver. "I'm the victim," he said.

The incidents occurred at Williamson's rented townhouse on Arley Drive in the Springfield area. In the first, neighbor Joyce Giuliani testified that she heard moaning coming from Williamson's house about 6:15 a.m., then singing at 6:35. On her way to work a few minutes later, she said, she drove past the townhouse, glanced at it and saw a man standing in the front window "unclothed."

Yvette Dean testified that about two hours later, at 8:40 a.m., she and her son were walking single file on a footpath near the side of Williamson's home. She said her son was in front of her, so she darted up to him and put a coat over him so he couldn't see. They continued walking toward the sidewalk on Arley Drive on their way to Hunt Valley Elementary School. "I looked again," Dean said. Williamson had moved to a window at the front of the house, still offering a fully unobstructed view of himself, she said.

He said he made coffee, did some cleaning, made breakfast, packed some more. He said he never stood in front of either the open doorway or the front window, was merely going about his morning business and didn't intend to expose himself. "It didn't cross my mind" that pedestrians might see him, he said. There were curtains on the windows, he said, but they were open.

"I believe from the evidence here," Judge O'Flaherty said, "that the gentleman obviously was intentionally naked in the house. I find that the windows were completely uncovered. The fact that it went on for so long indicates an obscene display, and I find the gentleman guilty." O'Flaherty sentenced him to 180 days in jail, all suspended for one year. He imposed no fine, just court costs of about $72, which Williamson didn't have to pay because he appealed.

My question to you: Do you think this man should be punished for being naked in his home?

full washington post article

Tags: home, man, naked, punished

Views: 111

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I think he should have been given a warning with a fine. Jail time seems inappropriate.
if its his home he makes the rules.. and why do they have to look inside of his house anyway?
i would say, they should mind their own business and leave the man alone.
American's are too hung up on nakedness.
Nah...the man is naked ...so ?

Live images of dead or dying people are being fed to me everyday on the 8 'o clock news. I remember a time that the news made me so depressed i had stopped watching it altogether for almost 2 yrs.
I don't think being naked is a big deal, but if there was some dude flashing my kids on purpose, I would be pissed! It's hard without knowing all the facts if the guy was being a perv or not.

I guess the real threat would be if he took it to the next level, and sexually assaulted somebody, especially a kid.

If it was some dude being careless about being naked, the punishment is too harsh. If it's some perv that gets off by flashing kids, the punishment is just.
Yeah I know right... pedophile perv is something else entirely.
well we all forgot to mention that his wife is the only one who could punish him for showing his "peter" to the rest of the neighbourhood... lol
No, he was in his own home. Maybe he should get some blinds though, or something.
Those 180 days in jail could potentially do more damage to that man then what he may have had mistakenly done to any on lookers.

This is somewhat off topic but not to long ago a friend and I were visiting the states (from Canada) and got picked up for drunk in public. Anyways at the time when we should have been released in the morning, they kept us accusing us of being illegal immigrants from Mexico even though we had all our identification and are pretty white as day. It got to the point when (over a 20 hr period) we were put in cells with other cell mates and given material to read covering how to avoid rape from other inmates.

The point Im making is at time jail sentences are so frivalously handed out without thinking about what damage could be done to the person. As other have said give him a warning and people should stop peeping in HIS house.

Sorry for the long story lol.
This is very true. In my opinion jail/prison should be for violent offenders.and everyone else should do community service. You can learn valuable lesson helping others or other lessons by being around harden criminals. Our prison system operates on a "for profit" model so locking people up makes sense to those who benefit financially.

You must have ran into some stupid cops if their mistaking white guys from Canada for Mexicans.
You make a great argument, Kevin.
Well at one point after telling them countless times that I drove from Ontario Canada through Buffalo, they asked if I was sure I didn't mean Mexico.

I'm not sure if they realized but Virginia Beach does not seem like the greatest destination point for illegal immigrants. Not much opportunity there.

Truly I am just glad I had 3 smart who weren't arrested because they had to spend the whole day with immigration proving to them (with out passports) that we were Canadian citizens. Since it was near the end of the day immigration wanted to just leave us in gen. pop. for the weekend but luckily I have persistent friends.

RSS

ADVERTISEMENT

© 2013   Created by alice.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service